How and Where the Top Wild West Legends Died (vol.5)

How and Where the Top Wild West Legends Died (vol.5)

Newspapers once branded Kid Curry the most dangerous outlaw in the American West, a reputation that made him the Wild Bunch’s most feared gunman even as Butch Cassidy handled the scheming and the Sundance Kid charmed his way through the frontier. Curry, born Harvey Alexander Logan around 1867 on a scrub farm near Richland Township, Iowa, earned his legend through cold efficiency rather than charisma. He was the man who shot pursuing posse men out of the saddle, leapt from moving trains with a revolver in each fist, and left Pinkerton detectives tallying the bodies behind him. Logan’s early life offered little stability.

Thumbnail

His mother died when he was young, his father drifted away, and the boy and his three brothers moved south with cowboy outfits into Texas. Ranch work sharpened his riding skills, but trouble followed close behind. In 1883, a wage dispute flared into a fistfight, then gunfire. Local accounts say Logan’s opponent went down, and the teenager fled north to avoid a noose.

By the time he reached the mining camps of Montana Territory, people called him Kid Curry. The nickname borrowed “kid” from his youthful frame and “Curry” from a horse breaker’s family he had once bunked with. Montana suited his restless nature. He worked cattle on the vast open range, traded bronco busting for poker, and tested his nerve against hard men in the saloons along the Judith Basin.

In 1894, he and his brother Johnny tangled with a lawman in Landusky. Logan claimed the marshal had insulted his Apache companion, Annie Rogers. The argument exploded into gun smoke, leaving the marshal dead and Curry’s face on wanted posters across the territory. From that moment, Curry’s life became a constant race between one posse and the next.

He roamed south into Wyoming and stepped into Butch Cassidy’s growing train robbery syndicate. Between 1896 and 1901, the Wild Bunch, including Cassidy, Sundance, Curry, and assorted saddle partners, struck rail lines and banks from Belford to Folsom. Curry was the spear point when the gang looted the Union Pacific payroll near Wilcox in 1899. It was Curry’s rifle that cut down Sheriff Joe Hazen during the pursuit that followed.

When the gang hit the Winnemucca Bank in Nevada, detectives whispered that Curry handled crowd control with unnerving calm. Pinkerton agent Charlie Siringo called him the coldest killer in America, crediting Curry with at least nine lawmen slain. Authorities in Wyoming, Montana, Utah, and Colorado each offered a $1,000 reward for his capture, a staggering sum in an era when a cowhand earned 30 dollars a month. The Wild Bunch posed for their famous Fort Worth studio portrait in 1900, dapper in new hats and silk vests.

Curry’s glare in that photograph seemed to dare every sheriff in the land to come and collect the bounty. The dragnet tightened that winter when a tip led deputies to a log cabin near Knoxville, Tennessee. A ferocious night gunfight followed. One deputy died, another was crippled, and Curry escaped by stealing a locomotive, blasting through railroad yards until the boiler ran dry.

Captured at last in Knoxville on a second sweep, he broke free again. He sawed through jail bars with a contraband file, overpowered the turnkey, and vanished into pine thickets before dawn. By 1902, the Wild Bunch had scattered. Cassidy and Sundance sailed for South America, while Curry drifted through New Mexico Territory under aliases.

He hired out as a wrangler on the VVV outfit and then slipped north into Colorado’s Grand Valley. There, on the hot afternoon of June 7, 1904, two masked men, one widely believed to be Curry, held up a Denver and Rio Grande express near Parachute. They blew the safe for $4,000, galloped into the Book Cliffs, and ran straight into a posse led by Sheriff Jesse Tyler. What happened on the steep sage slopes above Parachute Creek reads like the final chapter of a dime novel.

Cornered in a box ravine, the outlaw exchanged rifle fire until his horse was killed. He then staggered out, bleeding from the leg. Witnesses heard a final revolver shot that was not answered by the posse. When deputies advanced, they found a stocky man lying on his back, his hat over his face, a Colt still warm in his hand.

A bullet had pierced his head from temple to temple. They concluded he had taken his own life to cheat the hangman. Papers identified the dead man as Kid Curry. Undertakers embalmed him hurriedly in Grand Junction, and the body was buried under a stone marked Harvey Logan, 1904.

Yet the grave did not silence rumor. Some insisted the corpse was too short and the jaw not square enough. Others swore Curry had been spotted in South America months later, riding with Cassidy once more. Pinkerton files list him as deceased, but they also record letters hinting that he lived on under a new name in Texas.

No definitive photograph of the body survives, and modern DNA tests have never been run. Historians remain caught between eyewitness certainty and outlaw folklore. Verified or not, the story fits the man. Kid Curry spent a career eluding certainty, breaking chains, and slipping through cordons that would have trapped a slower spirit.

If he died on that Colorado hillside in 1904, he did so on his own terms, firing until the last cartridge and granting the law no triumph. If he escaped, then the parched winds that whip across Parachute Canyon may still carry his laughter. What remains clear is the trail of violence he left behind. Unlike Cassidy’s genial robber baron persona, Curry’s legacy leans toward the bleak edge of frontier freedom, where a quick draw settles arguments faster than any court and remorse rides light in the saddlebag.

Children of posse men he gunned down remembered him as a devil. Ranch hands who once shared coffee with him recalled a polite man who paid wages on time and never lied. That duality, killer and comrade, brute and loyal partner, keeps his legend flickering like a campfire flame.